STACY ADAMS Men’s Dickinson Cap-Toe Lace-up Oxford Review

STACY ADAMS Men’s Dickinson Cap-Toe Oxford Review: Unveiling a classic lace-up style. Get informed before you invest in this sophisticated footwear.

Men’s fashion has come a long way in recent years, with more and more emphasis being placed on style, comfort, and quality craftsmanship. For the modern man looking to upgrade his wardrobe, a good pair of leather dress shoes is a must-have. In this detailed review, we’ll be taking a close look at the Stacy Adams Men’s Dickinson Cap-Toe Oxford in the stylish burgundy color. With its sleek design and quality construction, this cap-toe Oxford is perfect for both casual and formal wear.

Overview of the Brand

STACY ADAMS Men's Dickinson Cap-Toe Lace-up Oxford
STACY ADAMS Men’s Dickinson Cap-Toe Lace-up Oxford

For over 100 years, Stacy Adams has been crafting fine men’s footwear. Founded in 1875 by William H. Stacy and Henry L. Adams in Brockton, Massachusetts, the brand has always focused on merging style and comfort. Stacy Adams uses high-quality leathers and materials and is renowned for their signature detailing and craftsmanship.

Check Price On Amazon

While Stacy Adams produces everything from casual sneakers to dress boots, they are perhaps best known for their sleek cap-toe Oxford dress shoes. Clean lines, beautiful leathers, and subtle decorative touches define the Stacy Adams aesthetic. Their shoes offer modern style while respecting classic tradition.

Key Features and Benefits

  • Premium leather upper – Constructed from full-grain leather for flexibility and durability. The rich burgundy shade looks great with both casual and formal wear.
  • Leather lining – The interior is lined with smooth leather which prevents rubbing and helps wick moisture. Comfortable even when worn for extended periods.
  • Leather sole – The genuine leather sole is handsome and long-wearing. Flexible and shock-absorbent.
  • Polyurethane heel – The low heel includes a polyurethane layer for additional stability and traction.
  • Cap toe design – The iconic cap toe styling gives the oxford dress shoe a polished, elegant look. Timeless and traditional.
  • Subtle perforated detailing – Perforations along the cap toe and sides give the shoe a touch of textural interest and visual appeal.
  • Cushioned insole – The padded footbed provides enhanced underfoot comfort and support. Reduces fatigue.
  • Moisture-wicking – Lining and insole work to keep feet dry and comfortable all day. Prevents odor buildup.

Review of Comfort, Fit, and Feel

Right out of the box, the Stacy Adams Dickinson oxford makes a sophisticated impression. The burnished full-grain leather upper has a rich, deep burgundy color with a subtle sheen. It’s clear this shoe is well-made, from the neatly stitched cap toe to the elegant perforated patterns along the sides.

Slipping the shoes on for the first time, you notice how flexible and lightweight they feel. The leather lining creates a smooth glide over the foot. Underfoot, the cushioned insole provides noticeable shock absorption and arch support.

In terms of sizing, the shoe runs true-to-size. However, the leather does have a snug break-in period. During the first few wears, the vamp feels stiff pressing on insteps. This is typical of leather dress shoes and improves as the material softens and molds.

Walking in the oxford, the leather sole feels delightfully springy yet still stable. The low heel includes a polyurethane layer for traction, making this shoe suitable for both indoor and outdoor wear. The padding around the collar helps prevent any heel slippage or blisters.

Overall, the Dickinson oxford offers a very comfortable, tailored feel. The premium leather provides flexibility while the cushioned insole keeps feet supported all day long. Attention to detail in the construction ensures a custom, friction-free fit. Once broken in, the supple leather upper and moisture-wicking lining maintain cool, dry comfort.

Style Recommendations and Outfit Ideas

The Stacy Adams Dickinson is a shoe for the stylish, modern man. The sleek cap toe oxford design projects sophistication and class. The burgundy shade gives the traditional silhouette a modern edge that sets it apart from standard black leather. This versatile shoe can be dressed up or down seamlessly.

For formal business or evening wear, the oxford pairs perfectly with tailored suits or dress pants. The burgundy shade complements navy, charcoal, and lighter grey tones beautifully. For black tie attire, the shoe adds the right pop of color to a classic tuxedo.

The Dickinson also integrates effortlessly into smart casual ensembles. Pair it with dark denim, chinos, or wool pants for an elevated casual look suitable for the office or date night. For weekend wear, try the oxford with relaxed khakis and an open collared shirt.

Burgundy is a color that spans the seasons, looking equally great with fall sweaters and lighter summer fabrics. For maximum versatility from this shoe all year round, stick to versatile neutral tones in shades like white, gray, tan, navy, or indigo denim on top.

Quality and Construction

The moment you hold the Stacy Adams Dickinson oxford, you can feel the quality craftsmanship. The full-grain leather upper has an immediately noticeable thickness and density. Stepping into the shoe, the padded insole maintains structure to provide support without excessive rigidity.

Check Price On Amazon

Details like neat stitching along the cap toe and collar evidence the meticulous construction. The soles display clean finishing with sealed edges to protect from wear. The polyurethane heel tap is securely attached. Design touches like the perforated patterns provide ornamentation without compromising on durability.

Inside, the moisture-wicking leather lining helps extend the life of the shoe by keeping feet dry. This prevents the growth of odor-causing bacteria. The leather welt attaching upper to sole is wide and substantial for security and strength.

The burnished aniline leather finish gives the burgundy shade depth while allowing the material to breathe naturally. With regular polishing, the rich color will develop a beautiful patina over time.

Made in China, the Stacy Adams Dickinson meets the brand’s reputation for fine detailing and quality components. With proper care and maintenance, this is a pair of dress shoes made to last years of regular wear.

Pros and Cons

Here’s a quick overview of some of the pros and cons of the Stacy Adams Men’s Dickinson Oxford in burgundy:


  • Handsome, sleek cap toe design
  • Rich full-grain leather upper with burnished finish
  • Leather sole provides flexibility and traction
  • Cushioned insole for continuous comfort
  • Moisture-wicking leather lining keeps feet dry
  • Versatile style works with various outfits
  • Good quality construction and materials


  • Snug break-in period as leather stretches
  • Perforated patterns may let water in if not treated
  • Requires regular polishing and maintenance
  • Runs large, so sizing down is recommended

Conclusion and Rating

The Stacy Adams Men’s Dickinson Cap-Toe Oxford in burgundy beautifully merges timeless style with modern comfort features. The full-grain leather upper provides both tailored structure and flexibility for all-day wear. Subtle perforated patterns and the burnished burgundy finish give this traditional cap toe Oxford a contemporary aesthetic.

Check Price On Amazon

Attention to detail in the form of padding, moisture-wicking lining, and traction-enhanced sole ensure comfort no matter how long you wear the shoe. Easy to integrate into formal, business, or casual looks, this versatile dress shoe is a wise investment for the stylish modern man.

Overall, the Stacy Adams Dickinson Cap-Toe Oxford in burgundy earns a rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars.

5/5 - (1 vote)

Leave a Comment